Matthew Smith teaches American history at Miami University of Ohio's Hamilton campus, where he also serves as regional director of public programs. This column first appeared on TheConversation.com.
With Sen. JD Vance named Donald Trump’s running mate, commentators are dusting off Vance’s 2016 memoir, “Hillbilly Elegy,” to explain America’s political moment.
Eight years ago, Vance was a Never-Trumper, comparing Trumpism to “cultural heroin” in an op-ed for The Atlantic.
Yet Vance’s book about growing up in a struggling city in southwestern Ohio became a go-to primer for explaining the Trumpian turn in American politics.One reviewereven likened Vance to an AppalachianTa-Nehisi Coates, revealing white, blue-collar America to outsiders in the same way that Coates’ writing explained Black America to white readers.
Today, with Vance on the Republican presidential ticket, national attention is once again turning to Middletown.
His hometown — just north of Cincinnati — risks becoming an abstract symbol of Rust Belt America. Ironically, it is easy to lose sight of the city’s rich, distinctive heritage, from which Vance’s memoir drew its potency.
As a British-bornscholar of religion and immigration, I stumbled into the study of Appalachia.
Twenty years ago, I could not have guessed the difference between a banjo and a mandolin, and would struggle to name a single bluegrass song.Dubious portrayals such as the horror movie “Deliverance” shaped my impression of Appalachian folkways.
'A night of hope':JD Vance speech transcript
Before moving to southwestern Ohio from Scotland, I could not have imagined teaching Appalachian history, literature and geography in classrooms with the grandchildren of eastern Kentucky coal miners. But my students at Miami University’s regional campuses taught me as much as I taught them – especially in Middletown, where in 2018 I read “Hillbilly Elegy” with my “Intro to Appalachia” class.
In search of Middletucky
Strictly speaking, southwestern Ohio is not part of Appalachia.
The state’s southeast, adjoining West Virginia, is considered the foothills of this mountain region. The southwest, on the other hand, bordering Kentucky, is squarely Midwestern, but strongly infused with Appalachian heritage.
As in Appalachia, varied landscapes and mass migration have shaped this corner of the state. In the mid-20th century, economic upheaval — most notably mechanization in the coal mining industry — pushed Vance’s grandparents and many thousands of fellow Appalachiansto seek new prospects in the Midwest, especially Ohio.
This migrationbrought with it the sounds of mountain and gospel music, the fervent faith of the Baptist and Pentecostal churches, and extendedfamily networksthat spanned generations.
Despite the traditional values borne by Appalachian migrants, Vance grew up in a world where the pejorative “hillbilly” retained the sting of prejudice, and where deindustrialization fed intocycles of unemployment and despair– patterns familiar in many areas of the United States that feel left behind by economic change.
“Our homes are a chaotic mess,” he wrote in “Hillbilly Elegy.” “We scream and yell at each other like we’re spectators at a football game.”
Yet family ties, especially to Appalachia – in Vance’s case, his grandparents’ hometown of Jackson, Kentucky – were among the few enduring strands of stability.
“My grandparents uprooted themselves from the real Kentucky and relocated to Middletucky in search of a better life,” wrote Vance, referencing Middletown’s sardonic nickname, “and in some ways they found it.” But they maintained ties across the Ohio River, and Vance’s fondest childhood memories were summer visits with family in Kentucky.
Former Ohio lawmaker:J.D. Vance a 'craven shapeshifter' regurgitating MAGA speak
By contrast, domestic violence and his mother’s heroin addiction overshadowed his homelife in Middletown. Like many children in this environment, Vance was raised by his grandparents, “Mamaw and Papaw” – to whom he attributed the tough love that set him on course to later succeed in the Marine Corps and at Yale Law School.
Mixed response
Many readers from Appalachiaobjected to “Hillbilly Elegy,” alleging Vance vilified their culture with bleak descriptions of opioid abuse, family dysfunction and social decay.
Just as importantly, many people criticized his analysis of what ailed the region. Vance described a culture of “learned helplessness,” in which the people around him lost self-reliance thanks to welfare dependency and moral decline. The region’s challenges “were not created by governments or corporations or anyone else,” he wrote. “We created them, and only we can fix them.”
Critics argued that this message deflected valuable attention away fromthe importance of wider factorslikeeconomic investmentand education – though Vance had written that the book was not about policies, but showing “what goes on in the lives of real people when the economy goes south.”
Plenty of my students objected to his book on just these grounds, but their wide range of responses revealed the complex nature of the region.
Sadly, the depiction of addiction, hardship and struggle resonated with many students. But not all identified with Vance’s Appalachian background, and among those who did, not all had encountered such struggles. The handful of Chinese students observed that China, too, has its Appalachias: mountain provinces shaped by coal mining.
Closer to home, students who proudly identified as Appalachian differed over Vance’s warts-and-all representation. Some found it condescending, some unflinching. Others rejected the label of “Appalachian” but identified with Vance’s heritage, noting that they too traveled “home” for family reunions in Kentucky.
The real Middletown
Like many Rust Belt cities, Vance’s hometown continues to struggle. Deindustrialization has taken its toll – notablythe decline of Middletown’s main employer, Armco Steel.
Household median incomeis around US$25,000 belowthe national figure. Thestate report cardestimates that just 1 in 5 high school graduates in Middletown is ready for the workforce, college or the military.
However, signs of progress belie the bleak depictions of “Hillbilly Elegy.” Entrepreneurial renaissance butts heads with Rust Belt stagnation in the city’s colorful downtown. Heavy manufacturing – immortalized by Kentucky songwriter Tom T. Hall’s “The Rolling Mills of Middletown” in 1972 — no longer drives the economy as powerfully as it used to.
Yet there are signs of growth and change.
A 2022 study by the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis estimated thatOhio’s creative industriesadded nearly $25 billion to the state that year, and the fruits are evident in Middletown.Sorg Opera House, founded in 1891 by a local millionaire, reopened in 2017 as the city’s prestige destination for the performing arts. And in nearby Wilmington, theIndustrial Strength Bluegrass Festival, founded by Middletown native and bluegrass musician Joe Mullins, welcomes nationally celebrated acts and audiences of thousands, drawn by the region’s rich artistic heritage.
Away from the glare of national politics, southwestern Ohio keeps building its future— and perhaps will proudly reclaim its unfairly maligned Appalachian heritage along the way.
Matthew Smith is a naturalized U.S. citizen originally from the United Kingdom. Smith teaches American history at Miami University of Ohio's Hamilton campus, where he also serves as regional director of public programs. This column first appeared on TheConversation.com.
